So we watched Towelhead the other night. I didn't realize until just now that it is an adaptation of a novel. Interestingly, that sort of changes how I feel about the movie.
There are spoilers here, because there is no other way for me to write about it. So don't read if you don't want to know what happens in the story.
The movie is advertised as a "coming of age" story, and I guess it is, but hopefully most girls' coming of age doesn't involve rape at the age of 13, followed immediately by consensual sex! I just could not help thinking during the entire movie "does this story need to be told?" It was well-done, the acting is excellent, the characters are believable, the story is believable (unfortunately). I just didn't really care to see it. I don't need stories of young girls being raped by their adult neighbors in my head (It isn't overly graphic. The movie is really excellently done.)
I'll admit that since becoming a parent I have a greatly reduced interest in any storytelling that involves children getting hurt. I also was not as aware of how prevalent a theme this is, but man, babies and kids getting hurt and killed is everywhere on TV and in movies. But even leaving that aside I think I would have had the same reaction. Did this movie need to be made? Is it worth my time watching it? I was definitely in the "no" camp...until I learned it is an adaptation of a novel.
For some reason, knowing that the story is a novel first and a movie second has made me think it has more worth. This same story as a novel would not have elicited the same reaction from me. Because a book is so much fuller than a movie, because a book is words and not images, a book is free to explore more unpleasant topics, in my opinion, than a movie. I would have preferred to have read this, rather than seen it.
What do you think? Are there stories, no matter how true or excellent, that just do not need to be told?
Part of me is just tired of our culture's (our world's?) obsession with young girls. I know that all of us came into our sexuality as teenagers and so it makes sense that we love the young because we were all young when it happened the first time...but there's got to be some maturity in us. We need to grow out of it as we age. Not that I wasn't relieved to learn that Taylor Kitsch is officially an adult (28! That's definitely adult age!).
I'm very susceptible to movies. I often have dreams (or nightmares, depending) incorporating whatever movie I've seen most recently so I try to avoid certain types of subjects, and wasn't expecting what I saw in Towelhead. Have you seen it or read it? What did you think?